Contacted by a majour designer's rep...Anomaly?

[LorrelMae]

Contacted by a majour designer\'s rep...Anomaly?

(I have thought about posting anonymous. I think the person may be on here or could figure it out. I am posting as "me" online.)

I have been contacted by a person who works for a majour label, trying to find antique, and vintage clothing, in any condition, any size.

My main concern, being a vintage freak, and somewhat on the greener (non-corporate) side is this: isn't it a tad disrespectful to copy old designs, and use for a new line of clothing, for a company that wields a mighty sword, already?

I guess I mean, do I want to be a part of it?

Yes and no.

Forgive me for being of two minds! I cannot help it!!

Anyone ever had this problem??

Unfortunately or fortunately, I already sent her photos of what I have. I have yet to get a response.

I just wondered if anyone else had some advice to offer.

Maybe to settle my head a bit.

I know it would be fabulous to see some things I have, in a modern day design.

I can't help but feel some disrespect for the "dead".

Yes, I know I take it all a tad too personal!! That is part of my problem!! I cannot help but think of the individual who may have owned the item!!

Thank you, in advance, of your reply!

 

[Jonathan]

Whether you think it is fair or not, the practise is common and has been going on for years. Designers like Ralph Lauren, Calvin Klein, and Anna Sui have been copying vintage designs for years. Most clothing designs, like recipes for cooking, are not copyrightable. Some Parisian Haute Couture is copyrighted if it post dates 1972 and a specific design is registered but there are lots of things that can't be copyrighted because they are already free domain -- you can't copright a dirndl skirt, or a dolman sleeve, or a sweetheart neckline or a stiletto heel. There was a high profile case a few years back where Yves St. Laurent sued and won against Ralph Lauren for copying a version of the tux style Le Smoking pant suit designed after 1972 but this is the only case I know of where the case was won. In the late 90s, Doc Marten was suing every known boot and shoemaker from Australia to England on points of trademark style infringment and didn't win one case of any significance with any monetary reward for their vigilance -- and it cost them a fortune.

At any rate, if you do or do not sell to a design rep is up to you, but there is probably nothing illegal being done and there are lots of sources for this purpose - they can buy on eBay, buy samples at the Manhattan Vintage clothing sale, take out a membership with FIT and study their collection...

 

[LorrelMae]

I know every designer does it, sometimes it's what I love about fashion. (Vivienne Westwood)

I am of two minds!

I will more than likely sell whatever they want, as they are doing no good wasting away in my box! And maybe they can inspire someone enough to give life to them again.

Thank you Jonathan!