To put it mildly, I prefer the paintings to the shoes :scratchchin:... Nothing against re-enacting the paintings in modern photography, but placing the shoes there is a total no-no to me.
What really, really got to me was the picture of Magdalene actually, looking at the bootie. I do not call myself a religious person, and was taught sober Zwinglian protestantism at school. My parents are not religious either, but they brought me up with a certain respect of religious things, which somehow is ingrained in me. I wouldn't even feel good taking pictures in a church. And that photo is just one of those things that, in short, feels completely wrong to me. Maybe blasphemous is the right word, though it does sound a bit strong to me, but I don't really know how to explain it. It's just a gut feeling that is wrong, that it is making something that to the painter at that time was a thing to be taken serious, look... mhhh... maybe frivolous?
And for re-creating the paintings... the crazy thing is, some of these old master paintings are more "alive" than any photograph would ever be - which is one of the reasons they fascinate me so much, and why Frans Hals one of my very favorite painters.
Karin